top of page

DID YOU KNOW? AMERICA HELPS FINANCE HEALTHCARE IN A COUNTRY WHERE HEALTHCARE IS A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT. BUT NOT HERE AT HOME.

11 hours ago
5 min read

During my congressional campaign, I came across something that troubled me deeply. The United States was providing hundreds of millions of dollars in assistance to an African nation to support programs that included universal healthcare. What caught my attention was not just the amount of money involved. It was the fact that this country recognized healthcare as a constitutional right.


That country was Kenya.


Article 43 of Kenya's Constitution explicitly recognizes the right of every person to the highest attainable standard of health, including healthcare services. It also provides that no person shall be denied emergency medical treatment.



Now consider this. According to the Congressional Research Service, the United States allocated approximately $479 million in bilateral assistance to Kenya in fiscal year 2024, largely for HIV/AIDS and other health programs.


And here is something else worth considering. On March 22, 2024, the United States House of Representatives approved the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2024 by a vote of 286 to 134, with support from 185 Democrats and 101 Republicans. The legislation included funding for the State Department and foreign operations, including international health assistance.


Hakeem Jeffries voted YES.


That is a matter of congressional record. House Roll Call Vote 102, March 22, 2024. Although Congress did not vote separately on Kenya's specific $479 million allocation, Jeffries supported the broader bipartisan appropriations legislation funding international assistance programs.


And that is yet another reason why I question the continued reliance on people like Hakeem Jeffries for congressional leadership. We have political leaders willing to approve substantial international health assistance while the United States continues to operate without a universal, legally guaranteed right to healthcare for its own people. That is not just a contradiction in our national priorities that deserves to be confronted, regardless of political party. It is hypocrisy!


And consider the magnitude of that investment. Since 2003, the United States has invested more than $8 billion in Kenya through PEPFAR, the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief. Eight billion dollars. That is an extraordinary financial commitment to protecting human health beyond our borders.


Let me be absolutely clear. I am not suggesting that America should abandon Kenya or stop helping people suffering from disease and poverty. Human suffering does not become less important simply because it occurs beyond our borders. International health programs save lives, and preventing infectious diseases abroad also protects Americans.


But there is a fundamental question that the American people demand to have answered. 


How can the United States recognize the importance of investing billions of dollars in healthcare for people living in another country while refusing to establish healthcare as a legally protected, universal right for the people whose tax dollars help finance that assistance?



This is not about choosing between Americans and Kenyans. It is about asking why the American government can recognize a responsibility to protect human health internationally while treating comprehensive healthcare access here at home as something dependent upon employment, insurance coverage, financial circumstances, and political negotiations.


And the contradiction goes even deeper. The Constitution of the World Health Organization, adopted in 1946, recognizes the highest attainable standard of health as a fundamental human right. The United Nations' Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1948, recognizes medical care as part of an adequate standard of living. That may be one of the reasons why Trump withdrew the United States from WHO.


Yet nearly eight decades later, the United States still does not recognize a general constitutional right to healthcare. We have Medicare. We have Medicaid. We have the Affordable Care Act, which is not a healthcare delivery system. It is a gateway to make attaining healthcare easier. We have emergency-treatment protections. These programs and laws have helped millions of Americans, and their importance should not be dismissed. But none of them establishes a comprehensive, universal guarantee of healthcare for every American.


And that is precisely why I developed the American Health Security Act (AHSA).


The AHSA is not another attempt to patch the holes in a healthcare financing system that has been patched repeatedly for generations. It is a proposal to fundamentally change how Americans obtain and pay for healthcare. First and foremost, under AHSA, healthcare is considered a human right.


Under the AHSA, every eligible American would be automatically enrolled in a comprehensive national healthcare program. Covered care would not depend on whether someone could afford an insurance premium, deductible, copayment, or other covered-service charge. Medical care, dental care, vision, hearing, mental health services, prescription medications, naturopathic and homeopathic protocols, and long-term care would be included. Patients would retain freedom of provider choice, while the program would establish national standards, negotiate prescription drug prices, and operate with dedicated financing and oversight.


The objective is straightforward: Healthcare should be available because you are a human being, not because you have the financial resources to purchase access to it.


There is an important distinction between recognizing healthcare as a human right and guaranteeing that every person will receive the care they need. A constitutional declaration alone does not build hospitals, train physicians, or pay medical bills. Kenya itself continues to struggle with healthcare access and financing despite its constitutional protections. That is why the AHSA addresses the actual delivery and financing of healthcare rather than relying on a declaration of principle alone.


We have spent decades arguing about who should pay, which insurance company should administer coverage, what services should be included, and how much financial hardship Americans should be expected to endure before receiving medical attention. Meanwhile, people delay treatment because they cannot afford it. Families face devastating medical bills. Workers remain tied to jobs because they fear losing their insurance. Older Americans struggle with expenses that can consume their retirement income.


And don't even start talking about trying to understand Medicare Part A versus Part B, or whether your deductible is met or if you're responsible for a copayment. Under AHSA, all of that goes away.

Illness does not discriminate between Democrats and Republicans. Cancer does not ask how someone voted. A heart attack does not wait for an insurance company to approve a claim. Healthcare is not a partisan issue. It is a human issue.


And we must stop pretending that the only choices available to Americans are preserving the current system or making small adjustments around its edges. The United States has the economic resources, medical expertise, technological capabilities, and institutional capacity to undertake meaningful healthcare reform. Whether and how we finance that reform are serious questions that deserve transparent answers and responsible legislation. That is the conversation the AHSA is intended to begin.



We should not have to look to the constitution of another nation to find a principle that ought to be reflected in the healthcare protections available to Americans. If we can recognize the importance of protecting human health abroad, we can recognize its importance here at home.


If we can help finance lifesaving treatment for families thousands of miles away, we can develop a system that protects families in North Carolina, Oklahoma, California, and every other state. And if we are serious about putting the American people first, then access to healthcare must be more than a campaign promise repeated every election cycle.


It must become a commitment reflected in the laws, institutions, and priorities of this nation. That is the purpose of the American Health Security Act.


Healthcare is a human right. It is time for American law to reflect that principle.


I'm Keith Davenport and I approved this message.


Keith Davenport


Comments


bottom of page